The BEST Copycat Sonic Cherry Limeade Recipe

Inside: A spot-on homemade version of the famous Sonic Cherry Limeade.

Do you love Sonic’s Cherry Limeade? It’s one of our favourite treats in the summer and I recently wanted to serve it at a family barbecue. Rather than hit the drive-thru, I went the DIY route for this easy Copycat Cherry Limeade recipe to serve a crowd!

The BEST Copycat Sonic Cherry Limeade

My family loves Cherry Limeade but we live a considerable distance to our nearest Sonic’s, so rather than make the long drive just for a few cups of this thirst-quenching treat, I’ve taken it upon myself to concoct the perfect homemade cherry limeade to satiate our cravings!

I’ve tried a few other copycat cherry limeade recipes and they all lacked that tart lime flavour that makes the Sonic treat so perfect.

Simply using a lemon-lime soda does not cover it — the lime needs to be stronger to really counter the sweetness of the maraschino cherry syrup. Adding store-bought limeade still gets too diluted once you add the soda for fizziness… and lime juice is ironically way too tart! (Who would have thought?!)

Related: For hours of fun sensory play, check out our Edible Cherry Limeade Slime for kids too!

The perfect solution?

Frozen limeade concentrate – as is. In it’s frozen, cylindrical glory straight from the freezer. As in, do not dilute it with water.

Just pop the frozen limeade (or let it thaw and pour in the fully concentrated liquid – your call) into your pitcher and add the other ingredients called for in this recipe.

You can also substitute grenadine for the cherry syrup called for, but since you’re probably going to want some cherry garnishes for your drinks I figured, might as well just use the syrup straight from the maraschino cherry jar! Top with some lemon-lime soda (whatever your favorite brand is) and then serve for a sparkling cherry limeade soda just like Sonic’s Cherry Limeade!

This Sonic Cherry Limeade recipe hits that perfect balance of sweet and tart and has that amazing sweet & sour cherry taste that is just so crazy delicious and sippable! If you’ve never had cherry limeade, it’s quite similar to a strawberry lemonade in terms of that same fruity citrus punch taste, but obvious the cherry and limeade changes the flavor profile.

(PS – everyone at the party thought this was the real deal and then asked for the recipe when they found out our cherry limeade was homemade! Mission accomplished! The only problem was that I didn’t prepare nearly enough and had to send my mom to the grocery store to pick up more supplies to keep everyone’s glass full! So, don’t make my mistake and double or triple this recipe if you are planning to serve a crowd! It will save you a bit of time in the kitchen and keep all of your guests happy.)

I hope you get a chance to make this delicious limeade recipe for your family or summer party and that everyone loves it! It would also be a special treat for a family movie night along with some homemade popcorn or crunchy honey glazed crockpot chex mix.

–– Jennifer

Be sure to check out our recipe video that shows just how easy this Copycat Sonic Cherry Limeade is to make – and then scroll down to grab the free printable recipe.

Copycat Sonic Cherry Limeade Ingredients

• 2 liter bottle lemon-lime soda (like Sprite)
• 1 can frozen limeade concentrate
• 1-6oz jar maraschino cherries, with syrup
• 1 lime, sliced

Tip: Make lots of ice for serving this recipe. Have extra ingredients on hand in case you want to adjust – more soda or less syrup, etc.

Tip #2: remember, if you don’t want to use the cherry syrup that the cherries come in, you can use grenadine or cherry syrup – they are basically the same thing!

Kitchen Tools You May Find Helpful

• Ice cube trays
• Large pitcher

How to Make Copycat Sonic Cherry Limeade

Combine lime juice concentrate, soda, and cherry syrup in a large pitcher and stir together until well mixed.

(Note: you can use the frozen limeade or let it thaw. It’s personal preference.)

Before serving, fill the pitcher or your serving glasses with ice. Garnish with lime and cherries, as desired.

Enjoy!

 

Pin this easy Copycat Sonic Cherry Limeade recipe for your next summer party:

Grab your free printable for our delicious Cherry Limeade recipe:

Have you ever had Sonic Cherry Limeade? If not, you really need to try this delicious nonalcoholic punch recipe for your next summer party. Which drink recipe would you like us to come up with a copycat recipe for next?

For more delicious summer drink ideas, check out our Moana Hawaiian punch recipe or our Morning Glory smoothie recipe.